There's a Problem in Academia When Faculty Think Students Are Learning Skills They Are Not
Let me start by saying I believe there is a future in and for writing and writers. Artists and communicators who have a true passion for words demonstrate a skill that cannot be replaced by gen-AI/LLMs.
But for those dispassionate folks, the ones in-between, whose enthusiasm for the written word and its potential is low and who at best will probably attain a kind of mid-level proficiency, many are relying on gen-AI as a crutch to provide a simulation of a skill they never intend to gain.
With such students, educators—especially in busy classes—may not notice the lack of student interest or investment and may think that, due to the arrival of seemingly proficient essays on their desks, students are actually learning certain basic reading, writing, and communication skills in the class. And if they are not, this disconnect is a problem, and one that I do not think is currently being adequately addressed in academia.
It goes fundamentally beyond the question of “cheating,” and I think it cannot be reduced, either, to ethical arguments about water use or the dangers to existing artists or even the stereotypes perpetuated by LLMs trained on problematic and disparate content, compelling as those arguments are.
Some students simply WILL use gen-AI. Given this, how should educators approach the challenge of education?
A friend of a friend, a writer and philosopher at Williams College, recently published an opinion piece in the New York Times in which he makes the case for grading students based on oral discussions and putting less emphasis on written assignments. If they can talk well about an assigned reading, they demonstrate the desired learning, he argues.
Which makes the class that I am currently teaching—College Writing, a required course for incoming freshmen—sound either superfluous or impossible. It would be like teaching a baking course in which if students could recite or summarize a recipe, I’d assume they knew how to bake the cake, when we all know that memorization of facts and the practice of producing something are indeed different skills and must be learned differently. It will be quite handy for the baker to have all their recipes memorized, but if they can’t figure out how to pre-heat the oven, or do the multi-tasking required to combine the ingredients together in the right time frame and know when the cake is cool enough to frost (skills learned through practice), it will be a moot point. And while memorizing the steps to write an essay is better than using an LLM to save you having to do any work at all, there are many students who may never memorize all the steps and yet who will, through practice, find their way into writing truly excellent papers.
At the moment, I do not know how to teach these two different sets of students in a single class—the ones who would be better served by memorizing a list of steps than by doing nothing, and the ones who will earnestly throw themselves into a process and learn through the messy art of doing.
Some educators are going back to having students write with pen and paper. But there is no way to keep out the creeping influence of phones in folders or under desks, or the huge number of students with accommodations that provide them with distraction-reduced environments in which they cannot be observed, providing students with access to instant internet content to input into their bound and lined journals.
Perhaps it is time to make writing an elective? Because reading generated essays based on summaries feels like a foul and losing game. Who wants to read or have to sort through such sludge? It certainly isn’t the future of academia, so why are we continuing to give it purchase in the classroom?
I, for one, only want to work with the people who want to do the work and appreciate its value. Perhaps it used to be the case that students applying to colleges had some intrinsic belief in the value of the skills the colleges offered to teach them. If that’s no longer the case, perhaps it’s time for an organizational change.